Re: [HumJanenge] what is going on in the RTI world?

Dear "Sucheta Dalal"

You (or somebody impersonating you) posted a message titled "Re:
Serious Privacy breach by IC A.Dixit" to the humjanenge@googlewgroups
message board.

It can be viewed here. It is the 4th or 5th message in the series
http://groups.google.com/group/HumJanenge/browse_thread/thread/99983a4118679229
It was sent from the "suchetadalal@yahoo.com" and originated from IP address
202.154.168.142 which is a Mumbai based ISP
descr: SOFTCELLNET
descr: Internet Hosting Service Provider,
descr: Mumbai,
descr: INDIA
country: IN

Moral: Let he who cast the first stone be without blame.

Best wishes and for your cyber complaint.
Ashish

On 11/23/10, Sucheta Dalal <suchetadalal@yahoo.com> wrote:
>
>
> What on earth is going on???? they are now filing defamatory stuff against
> me. I
> have never posted anything as mentioned by Ashish Kumar> And who is this
> Raminder ... will someone from the RTI groups please explain what is going
> on
> here?
>
> I don't even want to be part of these groups. I was part of Mahadhikar and
> Humjanenge when Kewal Semlani and Prakash Kardelay were alive. If anybody
> follows the groups, you would know that I never ever post.
>
> I have only reacted becuase I have been put on the googlegroup without my
> consent and was bombarded with email from them.
>
> sucheta Dalal
>
>
>
>
> Re: [HummJanenge] Sucheta Dalal's email
> Friends
>
> Speaking as somebody in the media, it is clear to everyone that Indian media
> is
> riddled with corruption. Journos who get freebies and junkets to write
> slanted
> stories. Vir Sanghvis who promise something to 1 industrialist's lobbyist
> over
> breakfast then take money from his brother's lobbyist at lunch to write
> something unpalatable to both. No wonder the man is so fat / gross. The less
> said about Barkha Dutt the better.
>
> In Sucheta Dalal's case, we have a pillar of the 5th estate who ostensibly
> writes about stock market manipulations by broker syndicates/ cartels and
> SEBI's
> lack of regulation. Who feeds her these stories ? For years Shankar Sharma
> (First Global) was held up by her as giving 75% good stock tips based on
> their
> research. Then she changed her tune when the Tehelka mess began (including
> Tehelka's unaccounted sources of finance and price rigging). Some days Ms
> Dalal
> favours the big bulls, next day she runs down big bears like Nirmal Bang and
> Anand Rathi. Can we believe her. Someday audio tapes of Mrs
> Dalal's conversations with brokers will leak out, or somebody should apply
> for
> them in RTI from Income Tax or SEBI.
>
> The final irony is in her threat to use the police to shut down this group.
>
> Raminder
>
>
> On Tue, Nov 23, 2010 at 8:40 AM, ashish kumar <ashishkr1965@gmail.com>wrote:
>
> Ms Sucheta Dalal has posted an email to some RTI groups with the title
>>"Re: Serious privacy breach by IC A.Dixit".
>>
>>In her email she asserts that she is a friend of Central Information
>>Commissioner Shailesh Gandhi. But more importantly she attempts to
>>divert attention from the list of 40 names in the CIC proposed for the
>>5th RTI convention by the then CIC Wajahat Habibullah. Mr Habibullah
>>must explain why these names were posted to CIC website in
>>IC.Annapurna Dixit's name under "CIC Orders".
>>
>>Let us have a few (say 1 from 2) of these.controversial names
>>
>>1. Mr Jean Dreze
>>2. Dr Subir Gokarn
>>3. Prof Kaushik Basu
>>4. Mr Anand Mahindra
>>5. Mr Yogi Deveshwar
>>6. Mr Ratan Tata
>>7. Mr Mukesh Ambani
>>8. Mr O.P.Bhatt
>>9. Mr Gajendra Haldea
>>10. Mr S.K.Roongta
>>11. Mr N.R.Narayanmurthy
>>12. Mr Azim Premji
>>13. Mr Kumarmangalam Birla
>>14. Mr Rahul Gandhi
>>15. Ms Brinda Karat
>>16. Mr Arun Shourie
>>17. Smt Kanimozhi
>>18. Mr Vinod Mehta
>>19. Ms Shabana Azmi
>>20. Ms Nalini Singh
>>
>>Can Smt Dalal identify even 1 clean person in this shortlist, which
>>lists people very well known to her personally, from the
>>"politician-media--industrialist nexus" lobby which Habibullah
>>repeatedly drags into the CIC If not then why is she so quick to
>>divert attention from these names ? Considering her open friendship
>>with Shailesh perhaps Ms Dalal's name would be proposed to be a
>>speaker at the 6th RTI convention, right up there with Nira Radia's.
>>
>>Ashish
>>
>>
>>
> Sucheta Dalal,
> Managing Editor, MoneyLIFE Magazine
> Trustee Moneylife Foundation
> www.suchetadalal.com, http://suchetadalal.com/blog/
> www.moneylife.in - Tel: 022-24441060
> "All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do
> nothing." --- Edmund Burke
>
>
>