Breaking the Silence Finally on Child Sexual Abuse

http://www.pakistanchristianpost.com/viewarticles.php?editorialid=1627

Breaking the Silence Finally on Child Sexual Abuse. By Anjali Singh

Child Sexual Abuse is a topic few are ready to discuss much less
address. Thus it came as a welcome surprise when in May 2012 the
Indian Parliament enacted its first law specifically outlawing child
sexual abuse. Prior to that the Protection of Children from Sexual
Offences Act being notified, different forms of abuse with children in
India was covered by laws not designed to address them. So if a girl
suffered non-penetrative sexual abuse it would be classified as
"assault with intent to outrage the modesty of woman," and if a boy
suffered abuse it would be classified as per the draconian
anti-homosexuality law that criminalized, "carnal intercourse against
the order of nature."

But this would only help punish the perpetrator if the police and
courts would recognize the crime as non-penetrative sexual acts. But
whether the law would recognize it or not, Child Sexual Abuse has been
a reality that children in India have been facing continuously
irrespective of their gender or societal strata they belonged to. A
fact that a recently released report by Human Rights Watch confirms in
a report they released in Lucknow in February 2013. One look at the
report on child sexual abuse termed, "Breaking the Silence-Child
Sexual Abuse in India" and the horrifying reality would become more
than evident.

The report presents a dismal picture of child protection in the
country particularly when it comes to preventing sexual abuse of
minors within homes, schools and institutions. A comprehensive 82 page
report, complete with case studies and expert comments, it proves
beyond doubt the existence of child sexual abuse across classes.
Highlighting inaction against the perpetrators, Human Rights Watch
maintains while releasing the report that child sexual abuse in homes,
schools and institutions for care and protection of children is quite
common. They further stress that a government appointed committee in
January 2013 itself found that the government child protection
schemes, "have clearly failed to achieve their avowed objective."

And this when in a statement released by Louis-Georges Arsenault,
UNICEF Representative to India, clearly establishes children in India
are facing child sexual abuse. Arsenault states, "It is alarming that
too many of these cases are children. One in three rape victims is a
child. More than 7,200 children including infants are raped every
year; experts believe that many more cases go unreported. Given the
stigma attached to rapes, especially when it comes to children, this
is most likely only the tip of the iceberg. "

But as alarming as that sounds the current report released by Human
Rights Watch is not the only study done in India on a subject of child
sexual abuse. In 2007 the Indian government sponsored a survey called,
"National Study on Child Abuse: India 2007" through the Ministry of
Women and Child Development, GoI. The findings of the study was based
on interviews with 12,500 children in 13 different states, and
reported serious and widespread sexual abuse, thereby bringing on
record the gravity of the problem. Yet no concrete steps were
initiated to deal with the problem and Renuka Chowdhry, the then
Minister of Women and Child, went as far as describing the prevalence
of child sexual abuse in India as "a conspiracy of silence"

What was really disturbing was the fact that the survey confirmed that
72 percent of the victims said they were abused and they did not
report the matter to anyone. Only a small 3 percent of the victims'
families complained to the police or made the abuse public.
Interestingly, prior to the GoI study in 2007, an India NGO named
Recovery and Healing from Incest(RAHI) conducted India's first study
of child sexual abuse in 1998 called "Recovery and Healing from
Incest, Voices from the Silent Zone(New Delhi 1998). The study
interviewed 600 English-speaking middle and upper class women out
which 76 percent said they had been abused in their childhood or
adolescence. Shockingly 40 percent said they had been abused by a
family member mostly an uncle or a cousin. Yet despite the study
making its findings public nothing much was done by the government or
related agencies to address the problem with seriousness.

Explians Menakshi Ganguly, South Asia Director, Human Rights Watch to
Citizen News Service - CNS, "While great awareness has been raised
about sexual violence against women in India much less is known about
the problem of child sexual abuse in India. Those children that have
the courage to speak up against the sexual abuse they face, the
police, medical experts and even their families refuse to take
cognizance of it. The children are admonished for making the
allegations and reprimanded by authority figures as well. We too faced
a lot of difficulty in collecting information for the survey as no one
was ready to talk about the abuse they had faced." She adds, "The
interviews we conducted from April and June 2012 and more than 100
people were interviewed including independent and government child
protection experts and officials, police officials, doctors, social
workers and lawyers. We also spoke to eight victims of child sexual
abuse and relatives of another nine victims, who agreed to discuss
their experiences. One of the victim was a male and seven were
females."

The study also investigated cases of CSA within institutions both
private and government which had been well highlighted in the media
between 2011-2012. In the absence of effective monitoring of
residential care facilities like Apna Ghar and Drone Foundation in
Haryana where children were housed within an institution for care and
protection and abused by the people running the home were also
studied. Cases of sexual abuse within the Shiv Kuti Shishu Grih, a
government residential facility for girls in Allahabad, a city in
Uttar Pradesh had girls between the ages of 6-12 years facing sexual
abuse by an employee for over fifteen years and it was only discovered
by chance are also included. Cases from homes in New Delhi, Karnataka,
West Bengal, Goa, Haryana and Uttar Pradesh were studied where alleged
abusers were members of staff, older children and outside visitors
including police officers. But addressing child sexual abuse,
according to Human Rights Watch report is a challenge the world over,
but in India, shortcomings in both state and community responses add
to the problem, as victims who come forward make a complaint often
suffer as a result.

Ahmed, father of a 12 year old girl who was gang raped says, "My
family was ostracized after my daughter said she was raped. The attack
on her took place after three men abducted her one afternoon as she
was walking back to her home in the northern city of Varanasi in Uttar
Pradesh. We decided to inform the police after seeing her condition
and also as many school girls used the same street and we were afraid
for their safety. But instead of supporting me my neighbors shunned me
as my daughter was raped. The family of my elder daughter's fiancé
cancelled the engagement as they felt public knowledge of the attack
on my daughter would bring shame to their family."

But apart from facing social ostracism, Ahmed(name changed) also had
to face the ire of the enforcement agencies, "The police discouraged
me from registering the complaint and accused my family of lying. My
daughter was continuously saying she was raped, but the police told us
not to tell anyone and settle the case. When I refused the police
grabbed me and slapped me several times, they also beat up my son."
Similar insensitive approach of the police is stated by another 12
year old victim in the report. Krishna(name changed), also from Uttar
Pradesh says she was raped by a member of a politically influential
family. When she complained to the police, instead of taking action
against the perpetrator, they detained her at the police station over
12 days.

Recalls Krishna, "The police kept insisting that I change my statement
otherwise they threatened that something would happen to me. They
would also insult me and call me rude names. My parents kept trying to
see me but they did not allow them to talk to me because they thought
my parents would tell me to speak the truth."

While the CSA report exposes police apathy of in cases of abuse with
children it also make a strong point about the insensitive attitude of
the medical fraternity in dealing with child rape victims. Says
Krishna who went through a traumatic experience when she was asked to
go through medical examination post rape, "The doctor asked me to lie
down on a table and remove my clothes. When she examined me she
inserted a single finger inside me. It hurt and I was scared. I did
not like what the doctor was doing to me. She then said, "Oh, it was
just a small rape, it's no big deal."

According to Menakshi Ganguly, "The finger test has been banned by the
High Courts in most states, even forensic experts maintain that this
test has no scientific importance yet it is be constantly used on
victims. The doctors and medical experts examining a child who has
been a victim of rape maintained when interviewed by us that in the
absence of any training and guidelines on how to carry out
examinations of a child rape victims they have to use the existing
procedures which are extremely traumatic for a child. In most cases we
examined the finger test was used by doctors to examine a child rape
victim."

Agrees the mother of a three-year-old girl whose daughter had to
undergo a medical examination after being raped and sodomized by her
own father, "The whole experience was not only painful but distressing
for both me and my daughter. Instead of examining my child in a
separate room, the examination was done in a blood stained labor ward
in a govt hospital in Bengaluru which further traumatized her. The
doctor who conducted the examination was very young who knew nothing
of examining a rape victim, she kept asking my daughter if she had
bled and could she walk after being raped. Then she pulled my child's
leg back and she screamed in pain. After the examination my daughter
could not pee for 6-8 hours because of the severe pain."

As per Dr Shaibya Saldanha, a gynecologist who works with child sexual
abuse survivors in Bengaluru, "Most doctors simply do not have the
skills to perform such an important role. Unfortunately no doctor,
whether a general practitioner or a gynecologist or a pediatrician has
been given any training whatsoever regarding child abuse examination,
interviewing, how to take care, what are rehabilitation procedures,
medical and psychological needs of the child. They have no idea."

A situation that is even worse in states like Uttar Pradesh and Madhya
Pradesh shares Vinika Karoli , State Co-ordinator UP, Quality
Institutional Care and Alternative for Children, an organization that
facilitated the release of the CSA Study in Lucknow, "There were too
many cases happening in UP and MP and with no protection mechanism and
in absence of state rules on the Juvenile Justice Act it was difficult
to get a correct picture of the situation. Through an RTI we filed it
came to light that govt in UP was pinning the number of CSA cases in
2011-2012

Pakistan News
March 22, 2013
Karachi peace impossible until mafias eliminated: CJ Iftikhar ...
Second meeting of Parliamentary Committee ends inconclusively ...
Pakistan has positive engagement policy with Afghanistan: FO ...
Obama makes direct peace appeal to the Israeli people ...
Foreign policy to be reviewed if PML-N voted to power: Nawaz ...
Pakistan denies involvement in 1993 Mumbai attacks ...
powered by PakTribune.com


Trial of Pakistani Christian Nation By Nazir S Bhatti

Click Here
On demand of our readers, I have decided to release E-Book version of
"Trial of Pakistani Christian Nation" on website of PCP which can also
be viewed on website of Pakistan Christian Congress
www.pakistanchristiancongress.org You can read chapter wise by
clicking tab on left handside of PDF format of E-Book.
You can send your comments on
E-Mails nazirbhattipcc@aol.com
pakistanchristianpost@comcast.net


GET PAKISTAN CHRISTIAN POST AT YOUR HOME NOW



Amazingbible.org 5000
pages of Bible News,
Prophecy and Studies

Letter To Editor
WELCOME TO FREEDOM
Why family of Afzal Guru not moving J&K High Court for taking his body
from Government ?
False propoganda of Dr. Gosling against Diocese of Peshawar
Emergency Contraception Pill
Dr David Gosling responds to letter of Rev. Rashid Nazir about
Edwardes College Peshawar
Worried about Pakistani Christian after attack in Lahore
Should I call it God's plan or populace's will?
An Indian Christian have concerns for Pakistani and other around globe


© 2008 Copy Rights Pakistan Christian Post. All Rights Reserved.

--
- Urvashi Sharma
Contact 9369613513
Right to Information Helpline 8081898081
Helpline Against Corruption 9455553838
http://yaishwaryaj-seva-sansthan.hpage.co.in/

http://upcpri.blogspot.in/